Legal Implications of the Letting of a Boat

Renting boats may initially seem like renting a property that is part of the land, such as a house.

However, the problem some landlords have faced is determining whether renting a boat creates a tenancy or a license.

A tenancy creates interest inland; as the courts have found, a boat cannot constitute land even where it is permanently moored.

The leading authority is the case of Chelsea Yacht & Boat Company Ltd. v Pope [2000] EWCA Civ 425 (06 April 2000).

In this case, the boat was called “Dinty Moore,” and it was secured by ropes and an anchor.

Sometimes, the Dinty Moore would rest on the riverbed, and the occupant argued that this made the Dinty immobile and, therefore, part of the land.

Case history for renting a boat

However, the Court found that the Dinty Moore did not form part of the land required for the creation of a tenancy; therefore, no tenancy could have been created.

The occupant of the Dinty Moore was, accordingly, a licensee and not a tenant.

Lord Justice Tuckey stated:

“…the houseboat rested periodically on the riverbed below it and was secured by ropes and perhaps to an extent the services to other structures.

It isn’t easy to see how attachments in this way to the pontoons, the anchor in the riverbed and the rings in the embankment wall could make the houseboat part of the land.

One is bound to ask, “Which land?” In my judgment, there is no satisfactory answer to this question.”

Lord Justice Morritt stated:

The proper test is laid down in Holland v Hodgson as approved in Elitestone & Morris.

The Court must consider both the degree and object of annexation. The Dinty Moore is attached to the river wall and the river in the manner described by Tuckey LJ, ultimately by ropes and service connections.

Those ropes and services may be untied and disconnected without any undue effort to enable the Dinty Moor to be towed away by a barge.

Thus, the degree of annexation does not require recognising the Dinty Moore as a part of the land.

In a more recent case, Mew & Anor v Tristmire Ltd [2011] EWCA Civ 912 (28 July 2011), the Court had to consider whether “houseboats” formed part of the land.

The houseboats, in this case, were situated on wooden platforms. The Court applied the test laid down in the case Elitestone v Morris [1997] 1 WLR 687, in which a two-fold test was established:

1. What is the degree of annexation and
2. What is the purpose of the annexation?

The Court found that the houseboats did not form part of the land as they could be removed without being dismantled or destroyed. Accordingly, the occupants of the houseboats were licensees and not tenants.

In most cases where a boat is let, the boat will be let on a license agreement.

What are the risks of letting a boat?

Owners of boats need to be aware of the pitfalls and risks of renting a boat. There have been some nasty cases where owners have suffered financial loss and more.

Types of Boats Available for Rent

Sailboats

Sailboats are ideal for those seeking a tranquil sailing experience. They harness the power of the wind to glide effortlessly across the water. Various sizes and styles are available to suit every preference and skill level.

Motorboats

For those craving speed and agility, motorboats offer an exhilarating ride on the water. From sleek speedboats to spacious pontoons, motorboat rentals provide endless possibilities for watersports, fishing trips, and leisurely cruises.

Yachts

Indulge in luxury and sophistication with a yacht rental. Perfect for special occasions or leisurely escapes, yachts offer lavish amenities, breathtaking views, and unparalleled comfort on the open seas.

Benefits of Boat Rentals

Cost-Effective

Renting a boat eliminates the hefty expenses associated with ownership, such as maintenance, storage, and insurance. With affordable rental options, you can enjoy the thrill of boating without breaking the bank.

Flexibility

Whether planning a day trip, a weekend getaway, or an extended vacation, boat rentals offer unparalleled flexibility. Choose from hourly, daily, or weekly rental options to accommodate your schedule and preferences.

Exploration

Embark on a journey of discovery as you navigate pristine waters and picturesque landscapes. With a rented boat, you can explore hidden coves, remote islands, and untouched shorelines at your own pace.

Memorable Boat Rental Experience

Plan Ahead

Before setting sail, familiarise yourself with local regulations, weather forecasts, and nautical charts to ensure a safe and enjoyable journey. Take the time to inspect the boat thoroughly and familiarise yourself with its features and controls.

Pack Essentials

Pack sunscreen, snacks, water, safety gear, and navigation tools to ensure a comfortable and secure voyage. Remember to bring a camera to capture unforgettable moments along the way.

Respect the Environment

Practice responsible boating by adhering to environmental regulations, minimising waste, and respecting wildlife habitats. Leave only footprints and take memories with you as you explore the wonders of the natural world.

In conclusion, boat rentals offer a convenient and affordable way to experience the thrill of boating without the commitment of ownership. 

Whether you’re seeking adventure, relaxation, or romance, renting a boat opens up a world of possibilities on the water. 

FAQ

What types of boats can I rent?

Boat rental companies typically offer a variety of watercraft, including sailboats, motorboats, pontoons, jet skis, and yachts. The availability may vary depending on the rental location and company.

What are the requirements for renting a boat?

Requirements vary by rental company and location, but generally, renters must be of legal age (often 18 or 21 years old), possess a valid government-issued ID, and have a valid credit card for payment and security deposit purposes.

Are there any safety measures I should know before renting a boat?

Yes, safety is paramount when renting a boat. It’s essential to receive proper instruction on operating the watercraft, including understanding navigation rules, safety equipment usage, and emergency procedures. 

Always wear a life jacket and follow all safety guidelines provided by the rental company.

What are the risks associated with renting a boat?

Renting a boat comes with inherent risks, including:

• Accidents: Collisions with other boats, submerged objects, or shoreline hazards can occur, leading to property damage, injuries, or even fatalities.
• Weather Conditions: Inclement weather, such as strong winds, thunderstorms, or rough waters, can pose significant risks to boaters.
• Mechanical Failures: Malfunctions or breakdowns of the boat’s mechanical systems can occur, leading to potential safety hazards.
• Inexperienced Operators: Inexperienced or reckless operators may need more skills to navigate safely, increasing the risk of accidents.
• Legal Liabilities: Renters may be held liable for damages or injuries resulting from their negligence or misconduct while operating the rented watercraft.

How can I minimise the risks associated with boat rental?

To minimise risks while renting a boat, consider the following precautions:

• Choose a reputable rental company: Select a rental company with a good reputation for safety and maintenance standards.
• Receive proper instruction: Take advantage of any safety briefings or instructional sessions the rental company provides.
• Check weather conditions: Monitor weather forecasts and avoid boating in adverse weather conditions.
• Operate within your skill level: Stay within your skill level and avoid activities or manoeuvres beyond your capabilities.
• Use safety equipment: Always wear a properly fitting life jacket and ensure that all required safety equipment is onboard and functioning correctly.
• Follow local regulations: Adhere to all boating laws, regulations, and navigational rules applicable to your boating area.

What should I do in case of an emergency while boating?

In case of an emergency, remain calm and follow these steps:

• Notify authorities: Contact the local authorities or Coast Guard immediately to request assistance.
• Assess the situation: Evaluate the nature and severity of the emergency and take appropriate actions to ensure the safety of all passengers.
• Follow emergency procedures: Follow the emergency procedures provided by the rental company, including deploying safety equipment, such as life rafts or distress signals, if necessary.
• Communicate your location: Provide clear information about your location, including landmarks or GPS coordinates, to facilitate rescue efforts.

Am I responsible for damages to the rented boat?

Yes, as a renter, you are typically responsible for any damages to the rented boat caused by negligence, misuse, or accidents during the rental period. 

Review the rental agreement carefully and understand your responsibilities regarding damages and liabilities.

Is insurance available for rented boats?

Some boat rental companies may offer renters optional insurance coverage to protect against damages, losses, or liabilities not covered by the renter’s existing insurance policies. 

It’s advisable to inquire about insurance options and consider purchasing additional coverage for peace of mind.

Can I cancel or reschedule my boat rental reservation?

Cancellation and rescheduling policies vary by rental company, so it’s essential to review the terms and conditions of your reservation carefully. 

Be aware of any cancellation fees or penalties associated with changes to your reservation, and notify the rental company promptly if you need to cancel or reschedule.

Where can I find more information about renting a boat and safety guidelines?

For more information about renting a boat and safety guidelines, consult resources provided by reputable boating organisations, government agencies, and boating safety courses. 

Contact the rental company directly for specific questions or concerns about your rental experience.

Guidance on renting a boat – Blog.

The British Landlords Association is a national landlords association for UK landlords. It is one of the largest landlord associations in the UK. Join us now for £79.95!

Tel: 020 3903 2000

Date: 29th of March 2024

How to Manage the Risks of Abandoned Property for Landlords

London Chamber of Arbitration and Mediation (LCAM)

Landlord course for Members 2024

Latest 2024 Assured Shorthold Tenancy