When Can I Forfeit the Lease?
Forfeiture is one of the most potent remedies available to a commercial landlord. It allows the landlord to terminate the lease and regain possession of the property when a tenant breaches its obligations.
However, the right to forfeit is heavily regulated, and misusing it can expose a landlord to serious claims for unlawful eviction, damages, or applications for relief from forfeiture.
This article explains the circumstances in which forfeiture can be exercised, the procedures landlords must follow, and the risks involved.
Understanding Forfeiture
Forfeiture is the legal right of a landlord to end a lease early because the tenant has failed to comply with its terms.
Most commercial leases expressly contain a forfeiture clause, setting out the circumstances in which this remedy can be used. Without such a clause, the landlord has no automatic right to forfeit.
The two most common grounds for forfeiture are:
- Non-payment of rent
- Other tenant breaches (such as unlawful alterations, failure to repair, or unauthorised subletting)
The procedure and requirements differ depending on the type of breach.
Forfeiture for Non-Payment of Rent
Most leases allow landlords to forfeit immediately if rent is not paid. Traditionally, forfeiture for non-payment could be exercised by:
- Peaceable re-entry: Physically entering the premises, usually by changing the locks when the property is vacant.
- Court proceedings: Issuing a possession claim to have the lease terminated by judicial order.
Because non-payment of rent is straightforward and quantifiable, no prior notice is required. However, landlords must ensure:
- The rent is genuinely due and unpaid (taking account of any agreed rent suspension or grace period).
- No waiver of the right to forfeit has occurred. For example, if the landlord demands or accepts rent after learning of arrears, it may lose the right to forfeit for that period.
- The re-entry is carried out lawfully and without breaching the peace. Forcible entry can amount to unlawful eviction.
Forfeiture for Other Breaches
Where the tenant commits a breach other than non-payment of rent, the landlord’s right to forfeit is subject to statutory control under section 146 of the Law of Property Act 1925.
Before forfeiture, the landlord must serve a section 146 notice, which must:
- Specify the breach complained of.
- If the breach is capable of being remedied, require the tenant to rectify it.
- Provide a reasonable time for compliance.
- Require compensation if appropriate.
Only if the tenant fails to comply with the notice can the landlord proceed to forfeit.
Examples of breaches that usually require a section 146 notice include:
- Failure to repair or maintain.
- Unauthorised alterations.
- Breach of the user clause.
- Breach of covenant against subletting or assignment.
Some breaches, such as illegal or immoral use of the premises, may not be capable of remedy, and in such cases the landlord can proceed directly to forfeiture after serving the notice.
Method of Forfeiture
After compliance with section 146 (where required), the landlord can forfeit by:
- Peaceable re-entry: Entering the property and excluding the tenant. This must be done carefully to avoid allegations of unlawful eviction.
- Court proceedings: Commencing possession proceedings in the County Court or High Court. This is the safer option, especially where the breach is disputed.
Relief from Forfeiture
Tenants have powerful rights to seek relief from forfeiture, which can undo the landlord’s actions and reinstate the lease.
- For rent arrears, the tenant can usually obtain relief by paying all arrears, interest, and costs, even after forfeiture has occurred. Courts are generous in granting such relief.
- For other breaches, the court has discretion to grant relief if the tenant remedies the violation and pays compensation.
Because of this, forfeiture may not always be the outcome.
Waiver of the Right to Forfeit
A landlord can unintentionally lose the right to forfeit if it waives the breach. Waiver occurs where the landlord, with knowledge of the breach, treats the lease as continuing—for example, by demanding or accepting rent after the breach.
Landlords must be careful to avoid any action that might constitute waiver, especially once they become aware of the tenant’s breach.
Risks of Getting Forfeiture Wrong
Exercising forfeiture incorrectly can expose landlords to serious claims, including:
- Unlawful eviction claims: If forfeiture is carried out without a proper legal basis or procedure.
- Damages for loss of business or occupation: Tenants may claim significant compensation.
- Applications for relief from forfeiture: Even if forfeiture is lawfully carried out, tenants may regain possession by court order.
Because of these risks, landlords are strongly advised to obtain specialist legal advice before taking steps to forfeit.
Practical Considerations for Landlords
- Check the lease: Ensure there is an express forfeiture clause covering the breach.
- Confirm the violation: Establish evidence of arrears or breach before acting.
- Avoid waiver: Do not accept rent or otherwise treat the lease as continuing once a breach is known.
- Comply with section 146: Serve a valid notice where required.
- Consider proportionality: Forfeiture is a drastic remedy and may not always be commercially sensible. Alternatives such as rent recovery, specific performance, or damages may be preferable.
FAQs
Can I forfeit without a forfeiture clause in the lease?
No. Without an express forfeiture provision, the landlord has no right to terminate early.
Do I always need a section 146 notice?
Not for rent arrears. A notice is only required for other breaches.
What if the tenant disputes the breach?
Court proceedings are safer than peaceable re-entry if the breach is contested.
How much time must I give in a section 146 notice?
The law requires a “reasonable” time. What is reasonable depends on the breach. Minor breaches may allow short timeframes, but substantial works may require longer.
Can the tenant stop forfeiture after it has happened?
Yes. The tenant can apply to court for relief from forfeiture, often successfully if arrears or breaches are remedied promptly.
Conclusion
Forfeiture is a potent but risky remedy for landlords. The right to forfeit arises where tenants fail to pay rent or commit other breaches of the lease. Still, landlords must strictly follow statutory procedures, particularly under section 146 of the Law of Property Act 1925.
Peaceable re-entry remains possible for rent arrears, but unlawful eviction risks make court proceedings a safer option.
Ultimately, landlords must weigh the commercial benefits against the risks of forfeiture being challenged or undone by relief. Legal advice is essential before taking action.
Our top read blogs:
Free Legal Advice for Commercial Property Landlords in the UK
Why Landlords Are Increasingly Favouring Semi-Commercial Property Investments
The British Landlords Association is a national landlord association, one of the largest in the UK. The BLA is the only landlords’ association in the UK that represents and supports both commercial and residential landlords. Join us now for £89.95!
