What Happens if a Commercial Tenant Stops Paying Rent?
“What happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” This is one of the most common concerns commercial landlords face, especially in a volatile market.
When rent arrears begin to mount, landlords are often left in a difficult position, unsure of their rights, options, and legal remedies.
Understanding the correct procedure for rent recovery is essential to avoid delays, mitigate losses, and preserve the long-term value of the property.
In this comprehensive guide, we explore the legal tools available to landlords, including forfeiture, CRAR (Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery), and court proceedings, while offering insight into best practices and legal obligations under English law.
“What happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” is a question that demands a legally sound and commercially practical response.
Immediate Steps Landlords Should Take
Before diving into enforcement options, a landlord should follow these preliminary steps:
- Confirm the Default
Review the lease agreement carefully. Establish how much is outstanding, whether any grace period applies, and whether any previous defaults exist. - Communicate with the Tenant
Sometimes, arrears arise due to temporary cash flow issues or simple administrative errors. A prompt, professional enquiry could result in immediate payment or an acceptable repayment plan. - Document All Communications
Every call, email, and letter must be documented. Should the matter escalate, this documentation becomes evidence in court or tribunal proceedings.
Legal Options for Commercial Rent Recovery
Forfeiture of the Lease
One of the most effective remedies available to landlords is forfeiture—the right to end the lease due to the tenant’s breach (in this case, non-payment of rent). Forfeiture is a serious step that terminates the tenant’s legal interest in the property.
- Peaceable Re-entry:
If the premises are not residential (and unoccupied at the time), the landlord may re-enter the property without court proceedings. This must be done carefully, usually with a certified bailiff present, to avoid allegations of unlawful eviction. - Court Proceedings for Forfeiture:
If peaceable re-entry is not possible or advisable, the landlord may apply to the court to enforce forfeiture. This is a slower route but necessary in some instances, especially if the tenant contests the action.
Landlords must exercise caution: once a landlord accepts rent after a breach, they may be perceived as waiving their right to forfeit. Timing is critical.
“What happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” Often, the answer lies in whether the lease allows forfeiture and whether the landlord acts promptly and correctly.
CRAR – Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery
CRAR is a statutory process that allows landlords to instruct enforcement agents (certified bailiffs) to seize and sell a tenant’s goods to recover unpaid rent.
- Eligibility:
CRAR can only be used for commercial premises (no residential use allowed), and only for principal rent, not for service charges, insurance, or interest. - Notice Requirement:
The landlord must serve a seven-day notice on the tenant before taking enforcement action. During this period, the tenant may pay or challenge the notice. - Execution:
After the notice period expires, enforcement agents may enter the premises and seize goods equal to the value of the arrears.
“What happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” CRAR offers a swift, cost-effective remedy—but only under strict legal conditions. Misuse or misunderstanding of CRAR can render the process invalid.
Issuing Court Proceedings
If forfeiture or CRAR is not appropriate—or if a landlord seeks to claim other sums such as service charges, interest, or dilapidations—court action may be the best course.
- Debt Claims:
A straightforward debt recovery claim can be issued in the County Court. If the claim is undisputed, judgment may be entered quickly, followed by enforcement (e.g., charging orders, High Court enforcement, or third-party debt orders). - Statutory Demands and Insolvency Proceedings:
For substantial debts (over £750 for companies), a landlord may issue a statutory demand. If not settled within 21 days, the landlord may petition for winding up (for companies) or bankruptcy (for individual tenants).
Court proceedings are sometimes slow and costly, but can be effective for recovering large sums and establishing legal rights.
“What happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” In many instances, the answer is found in carefully managed litigation, particularly where lease terms are complex or the tenant is trading through a limited company.
Additional Considerations
Negotiated Settlements
Not every case must result in eviction or court action. Many landlords achieve better outcomes by negotiating revised payment terms, lease re-gears, or even early termination deals.
If the tenant remains solvent and the arrears are modest, a well-crafted repayment agreement may preserve a long-term relationship and avoid legal expense.
Rent Deposits and Guarantors
Landlords should not forget to check whether a rent deposit deed or personal guarantee exists. These instruments can provide direct routes to payment and bolster the landlord’s bargaining position.
Subtenants and CRAR
If a commercial tenant has sublet the premises, landlords may be entitled to collect rent directly from the subtenant under CRAR, provided specific notice is served. This is particularly useful where the head tenant is in default, but the subtenant remains in occupation.
Risks of Inaction
Doing nothing is often the costliest mistake. Rent arrears can mount rapidly, and tenant insolvency may render debts unrecoverable. Prompt, well-informed action helps landlords mitigate financial losses and protect their investment.
“What happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” The outcome largely depends on how early the landlord acts and whether they understand their rights.
How to Choose the Right Remedy
Selecting the right legal remedy depends on several factors:
- Amount of rent arrears
- Lease terms (forfeiture clauses, CRAR eligibility)
- Tenant’s financial status and likelihood of recovery
- Strategic interest (retain the tenant or replace them?)
- Costs and time involved
Legal advice is always advisable before taking any irreversible step, especially forfeiture or CRAR, which can escalate disputes if handled improperly.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Accepting Rent After Breach: This could waive your right to forfeit.
Improper Use of CRAR: Using CRAR for ineligible arrears (e.g., service charges) invalidates the process.
Failing to Serve Proper Notices: Whether using CRAR, court proceedings, or pursuing guarantors, service errors can nullify a landlord’s rights.
Letting Arrears Accumulate: Delayed action increases the chance of tenant insolvency and reduces recovery.
Conclusion
“What happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” is a serious question that requires a deliberate and informed approach. Whether a landlord chooses forfeiture, CRAR, or court proceedings, the key lies in understanding the lease terms, evaluating the tenant’s position, and acting decisively.
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but in every case, delay is the enemy of recovery. Landlords who act early, follow correct procedures, and seek professional guidance position themselves for better outcomes, financially and legally.
FAQs
Can I evict a commercial tenant immediately after one missed rent payment?
Not necessarily. The lease usually outlines a grace period. Forfeiture can only be enforced if permitted under the lease and typically after a specified period of non-payment.
Is CRAR available for mixed-use properties?
No. CRAR is strictly limited to purely commercial premises. If the property includes residential use, CRAR is not available.
What if the tenant goes into administration or liquidation?
If a tenant enters administration, landlords face a moratorium on enforcement action (including forfeiture). In liquidation, rent becomes an unsecured debt, meaning recovery is often minimal.
Can I still pursue a personal guarantor if the business tenant defaults?
Yes—if the lease is backed by a valid personal guarantee, you can pursue the guarantor for unpaid rent and related liabilities.
Do I need a court order to change the locks?
Not always. Peaceable re-entry is allowed under forfeiture if the property is wholly commercial and unoccupied. However, many landlords choose to go through the court to avoid legal risk.
Can I use CRAR and forfeiture at the same time?
No. Using CRAR first may waive your right to forfeit. It’s crucial to select one enforcement method, based on the strategy and lease terms.
Can I charge interest on unpaid rent?
Yes—if the lease includes an interest clause. If not, statutory interest may apply at 8% plus the Bank of England base rate.
What if the tenant disputes the arrears?
If there’s a genuine dispute, enforcement options like CRAR or court judgment may be delayed until the issue is resolved. Legal advice is essential in these cases.
Can I recover legal costs from the tenant?
Most leases include a costs clause, but recovery depends on the court’s discretion and whether enforcement action is successful.
Should I use a solicitor or manage the process myself?
Given the complexity of lease law and the risk of waiving rights, it is always advisable to instruct a solicitor familiar with commercial property litigation.
For landlords, understanding “what happens if a commercial tenant stops paying rent?” is about more than just knowing the law—it’s about applying the right strategy at the right time.
With the right knowledge and swift action, landlords can recover rent efficiently and safeguard their long-term investment.
The British Landlords Association is a national landlord association for UK landlords and one of the largest landlord associations in the UK. The BLA is the only commercial landlords association in the UK. Join us now for £79.95!
Our top-read blogs:
Is Commercial Property a Good Investment in England & Wales?
Commercial Property Rent Review Protocol
Investing in Commercial Property vs Residential Property: The Advantages and Disadvantages
