Do my tenants have security of tenure, and can I contract out?
The question Do my tenants have security of tenure and can I contract out is one of the most critical issues facing commercial landlords in the UK.
Security of tenure under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 offers business tenants powerful rights to remain in their premises when the lease ends.
However, landlords can exclude these rights by following a strict legal process before the lease is completed.
This article explores what security of tenure means, when it applies, and how landlords can effectively contract out while avoiding mistakes that could invalidate the process.
What is the security of tenure?
Security of tenure gives business tenants the legal right to remain in occupation at the end of their contractual lease term.
They can request a new lease and, unless the landlord proves specific statutory grounds for opposition, the tenant is entitled to continue their business from the same premises.
This protection ensures stability for businesses, safeguarding their goodwill and investments in a property. For landlords, however, it restricts flexibility because they cannot simply recover possession once the term ends.
The Landlord and Tenant Act 1954
The Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 governs most business tenancies in England and Wales. It applies where premises are occupied for business purposes, regardless of whether the lease expressly mentions the Act.
There are some exclusions, such as agricultural leases, mining leases, certain short tenancies under six months, and tenancies granted by public authorities. For the majority of offices, shops, warehouses, and industrial units, the Act applies unless properly excluded.
Contracting out of security of tenure
Landlords and tenants may agree to contract out of security of tenure before a new lease is granted. This means that at the end of the lease, the tenant has no automatic right to stay or request a new lease.
Contracting out is common where landlords want maximum control, for example, in redevelopment areas or when flexibility in future leasing is essential. It is lawful, but only if carried out in strict compliance with the law.
The statutory procedure for contracting out
The process is governed by the Regulatory Reform (Business Tenancies) (England and Wales) Order 2003. The following steps must be followed precisely:
The landlord’s warning notice
The landlord must serve a prescribed form of notice on the proposed tenant before the lease is completed. This notice explains in plain terms the rights that the tenant will lose by agreeing to contract out.
The tenant’s declaration
The tenant must then acknowledge the warning by signing either:
- A simple declaration, if the lease is due to complete more than 14 days after the notice is served.
- A statutory declaration, if the lease will be completed within 14 days of the notice. This must be sworn before a solicitor or commissioner for oaths.
Lease wording
The lease itself must include a clause confirming that the statutory procedure has been followed.
If any of these steps are missed or incorrectly carried out, the lease will not be validly excluded and the tenant will still enjoy security of tenure.
Why landlords contract out
Landlords prefer contracting out in many situations:
- To secure control of property for redevelopment or change of use
- To avoid being tied to long-term tenancies when market rents rise
- To ensure greater flexibility in choosing future tenants
For landlords, the ability to recover possession at the end of a lease without opposition can be highly advantageous.
Risks of contracting out
Although contracting out gives landlords freedom, it carries risks:
- Tenants may be reluctant to invest heavily in fit-out or branding if they know they cannot renew
- Some tenants may refuse to sign up without the security of tenure
- Mistakes in the exclusion procedure can lead to litigation and costly disputes
Landlords must weigh the commercial benefits against the potential downsides.
The tenant’s viewpoint
From the tenant’s perspective, security of tenure is valuable protection. It gives them confidence to invest in premises, knowing they cannot be forced out arbitrarily.
Some tenants, however, accept contracting out if they only require a short-term presence, if their business is not location-dependent, or if they receive financial incentives such as rent-free periods.
Common mistakes
Errors that commonly invalidate the contracting out process include:
- Serving the warning notice after the lease has been signed
- Using an incorrect form of notice instead of the prescribed one
- Relying on a simple declaration when the lease was completed within 14 days
- Failing to include exclusion wording in the lease itself
These mistakes result in the tenant keeping full statutory rights under the 1954 Act, often against the landlord’s intention.
Renewal rights where security of tenure exists
If the lease is not contracted out, a tenant can request a new lease when the term ends. The landlord may oppose renewal, but only on statutory grounds such as:
- The tenant’s failure to repair or pay rent
- Persistent late payment of rent
- Substantial breach of obligations
- The landlord’s intention to occupy or redevelop
If the landlord proves a ground, the tenant must leave, though in some cases they may receive compensation. If not, the court will order a new lease.
Best practice for landlords
Landlords should always:
- Serve the warning notice as early as possible
- Ensure the correct form of tenant declaration is used
- Keep copies of all documents with the lease
- Insert precise wording in the lease confirming exclusion
- Obtain professional advice to avoid errors
This ensures that the contracting-out procedure is watertight and enforceable.
FAQs
Do all business tenants automatically have security of tenure?
Most do, unless the lease is validly contracted out or falls into one of the statutory exceptions.
Can a landlord end a lease if it has security of tenure?
Only if they can prove one of the statutory grounds, such as redevelopment, occupation, or breach of obligations.
What happens if the contracting-out paperwork is wrong?
The tenant keeps their statutory rights and can request a new lease at the end of the term.
Do tenants have to agree to contract out?
Yes, it is voluntary. A landlord cannot impose it without the tenant’s consent.
Why is timing so important?
If completion is within 14 days of the warning notice, a statutory declaration is required. Using the wrong declaration invalidates the process.
Conclusion
The issue of whether my tenants have security of tenure and whether I can contract out highlights the careful balance between tenant protection and landlord flexibility. Security of tenure under the 1954 Act protects most business tenants, giving them strong rights to renew their leases.
Landlords can, however, contract out of these rights, but only by following the strict statutory process of serving a warning notice, obtaining the correct tenant declaration, and recording the exclusion in the lease.
Errors can undermine the process, leaving tenants with complete protection despite the parties’ intentions. For landlords, the key is compliance, documentation, and professional advice to safeguard their position.
Our top-read blogs:
Free Legal Advice for Commercial Property Landlords in the UK
Why Landlords Are Increasingly Favouring Semi-Commercial Property Investments
The British Landlords Association is a national landlord association, one of the largest in the UK. The BLA is the only landlords’ association in the UK that represents and supports both commercial and residential landlords. Join us now for £89.95!
