Commercial Leases (Automatic Continuation etc.) (Scotland) Bill – Withdrawn September 2025
The Commercial Leases (Automatic Continuation etc.) (Scotland) Bill was introduced to replace Scotland’s long-standing common-law rule of tacit relocation with a clear statutory framework.
Its withdrawal on September 10, 2025, leaves the traditional system intact for the time being. Below, we explore what the Bill proposed, why it mattered, and what landlords and tenants should note going forward.
What Is Tacit Relocation?
In Scotland, most commercial leases do not end automatically on the contractual expiry date unless proper notice is served. Instead, they are extended for a further year on the same terms under the common-law doctrine of tacit relocation.
This continuation arises if neither landlord nor tenant serves notice of termination within the required statutory period (usually not less than 40 days before expiry).
The rule often catches out parties unfamiliar with Scottish practice, particularly international tenants used to automatic lease termination elsewhere in the UK.
The Aim of the Withdrawn Bill
The Bill intended to modernise and codify this area by replacing tacit relocation with a statutory “automatic continuation” code. The proposals would have:
- Provided a straightforward, statutory procedure for continuation of leases.
- Introduced more transparency around notice periods and obligations.
- Ensured tenants and landlords alike could plan lease endings with greater certainty.
- Reduced reliance on archaic common law principles and judicial interpretation.
In essence, the Bill aimed to update Scotland’s leasing framework to reflect modern commercial realities, while preserving continuity where neither party wished to terminate the arrangement.
Why Was the Bill Withdrawn?
On September 10 2025, the Scottish Government formally withdrew the Bill. No replacement legislation has been enacted yet. While no single reason was cited, several factors likely contributed:
- Complexity of stakeholder interests – balancing landlord protections with tenant flexibility proved politically sensitive.
- Legislative pressures – competing housing, rent control, and energy-efficiency priorities dominated parliamentary time.
- Relative stability – tacit relocation, though old-fashioned, continues to function reasonably well in practice, so reform was not viewed as urgent.
Practical Effect of Withdrawal
For landlords and tenants, the withdrawal means:
- No immediate change – tacit relocation remains in force exactly as before.
- Risk of inadvertent continuation – failure to serve proper notice still leads to a one-year automatic extension.
- Ongoing uncertainty – the possibility of reintroduction or alternative reform remains, so parties should keep informed.
Commercial lease negotiations and management in Scotland, therefore, remain distinct from those in England and Wales, where leases generally end upon expiry unless renewed.
Implications for Landlords
Landlords must remain vigilant in lease management:
- Diary lease expiries carefully – ensure termination notices are issued well in advance of the 40-day minimum.
- Check internal procedures – property managers, solicitors, and asset managers should align to avoid unwanted extensions.
- Negotiate clarity – consider lease clauses that reinforce notice obligations, even if tacit relocation applies by law.
Implications for Tenants
Tenants should also be proactive:
- Serve notice if you wish to leave – silence may bind you for another year on the same rent and terms.
- Budget for possible continuation – particularly relevant for businesses planning relocations or consolidations.
- Seek advice early – particularly if negotiating a break clause, renewal, or exit strategy.
Looking Ahead
Although withdrawn, the debate surrounding the replacement of tacit relocation is unlikely to disappear.
Commercial stakeholders may continue to push for reform, particularly if disputes highlight the shortcomings of the current system. For now, however, the legal landscape remains unchanged.
FAQs
Does tacit relocation apply to all commercial leases in Scotland?
Yes, unless a valid notice is served. Certain very short leases may operate differently, but the principle applies across the sector.
How much notice must be given to terminate a lease?
At least 40 clear days before expiry, unless the lease specifies a more extended period.
Can a lease contract be considered tacitly relocated?
Parties can agree on mechanisms for termination, but unless properly structured, tacit relocation may still apply. Legal advice is recommended.
Is there likely a new Bill soon?
No replacement legislation has been introduced yet. Future reform is possible, but timelines remain uncertain.
Conclusion
The Commercial Leases (Automatic Continuation etc.) (Scotland) Bill, withdrawn on September 10 2025, would have provided a modern statutory framework for the continuation of leases.
Its absence leaves landlords and tenants operating under the centuries-old common-law doctrine of tacit relocation. Until reform returns to the legislative agenda, both parties must remain vigilant to the strict notice rules that can unexpectedly extend leases.
Our top-read blogs:
Is Commercial Property a Good Investment in England & Wales?
Commercial Property Rent Review Protocol
Investing in Commercial Property vs Residential Property: The Advantages and Disadvantages
The British Landlords Association is a national landlord association, one of the largest in the UK. The BLA is the only landlords’ association in the UK that represents and supports both commercial and residential landlords. Join us now for £89.95!
